Mamaluke debuted in World Championship Wrestling (WCW) in 1999 as an unnamed fan of wrestler Lodi, debuting in a Nitro Party clip then appearing in an outdoor segment when Lenny Lane and Lodi were arriving at a show in New York. He then appeared as a fan invader during many of Lodi and his brother Lenny's matches until the angle was dropped when Lenny and Lodi were removed from television in late 1999.
He returned shortly as Tony Marinara, a New York mobster who managed the team of Big Vito and Johnny the Bull, who became known as The Mamalukes. His storyline included a feud with Disco Inferno, who owed his "family" money. At one point, the feud also involved Lash LeRoux. His last appearance came at the 2000 Souled Out pay-per-view. In an interview with Gene Okerlund, he said he had to take care of some business and then left, never to appear in WCW again.
Not long after his release, he started working in Extreme Championship Wrestling. He took on the name Tony Mamaluke. He joined The Full Blooded Italians, which consisted of Little Guido and Big Sal E. Graziano. His debut match was against Mikey Whipwreck on ECW on TNN, in which Tony Mamaluke took a couple hardcore bumps. Mamaluke was initially a member in training, until he became a full-fledged member when the tandem captured the ECW World Tag Team Championship from The Unholy Alliance on August 25, 2000, on day two of Ballroom Blitz. The two teams feuded for several months, with their respective managers, Big Sal and The Sinister Minister creating further conflict. They lost the titles, however, on December 3, 2000 at Massacre On 34th Street to Danny Doring and Roadkill. During this time, he also feuded with Super Crazy and Kid Kash. He stayed with ECW until the company was declared bankrupt in April 2001.
During 2005, WWE held a reunion ECW show entitled One Night Stand. Little Guido and Mamaluke appeared with other original Full Blooded Italians at the pay-per-view. In April 2006, WWE decided to revive ECW as a new brand, and Mamaluke was among several ECW alumni that signed contracts with WWE to participate as full-time competitors for the new ECW. Mamaluke debuted on June 7, 2006 at WWE vs. ECW: Head to Head, participating in the battle royal between ECW and a contingent of Raw/SmackDown! superstars.
Mamaluke made his pay-per-view debut at One Night Stand 2006, reviving his role as a member of the Full Blooded Italians with Little Guido; the duo was accompanied by Big Guido. The duo faced Yoshihiro Tajiri and Super Crazy in tag team action, picking up the victory. From there, he continued to team with Guido and was accompanied by Trinity. He only appeared sporadically on ECW on Sci-Fi in losing attempts in both singles and tag team action against the likes of Sabu, The Hardys, Mike Knox, and Test. The Full Blooded Italians appeared on pay-per-view once again on December 3, 2006 at December to Dismember, in a losing effort to Sylvester Terkay and Elijah Burke.
On January 18, 2007, Mamaluke was released from his WWE contract.
At NXT 2300 on November 6, 2024, Mamaluke returned to WWE alongside Nunzio, who unsuccessfully challenged Tony D'Angelo for the NXT North American Championship.