Prichard joined the World Wrestling Federation in 1993 alongside Jimmy Del Ray as The Heavenly Bodies, wrestling the WWF World Tag Team Champions the Steiner Brothers at SummerSlam 1993. On November 24, 1993, at Survivor Series, Prichard and Del Ray defeated the Rock 'n' Roll Express. At WrestleMania X, the Heavenly Bodies defeated the Bushwhackers in a dark match.
The Heavenly Bodies were released in the summer of 1995. However, Prichard fought in a couple of single matches against Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels before his release.
Prichard competed at the Survivor Series 1995, wrestling on future tag team partner Skip's team "The Bodydonnas." Prichard was the first man eliminated as the Bodydonnas defeated Barry Horowitz's "Underdogs" team. A month later, Prichard was officially introduced as Zip, Skip's on-screen cousin and tag team partner, interfering in a match allowing Skip to defeat Rad Radford, who had been trying to become a Bodydonna himself. Before this appearance, he had cut off his trademark curly long brown locks into a dyed blond crew cut, to more resemble his storyline cousin.
On the WrestleMania XII pre-show, on March 31, 1996, the team defeated The Godwinns in the finals of an eight-team tournament to win the vacant WWF Tag Team Championship. They held the titles until May 19, 1996, when they were defeated by the Godwinns in Madison Square Garden in New York City. After Skip left the WWF in fall of 1996, Prichard became a masked jobber named Dr. X. Dr. X fought mainly on house shows but made a few television appearances on Superstars. Dr. X lost to Brakkus at In Your House 12: It's Time.
On September 27, 1999, Prichard teamed up with Jeff Jarrett to face off against Chyna and Debra on Raw is War. Prichard hit Chyna with a guitar and Jarrett was knocked out cold as Chyna went for the victory.
In 2003, Prichard co-hosted Byte This! alongside Todd Grisham, the WWE's internet talk show. Prichard was released from WWE in 2004.