In late 1995, The Bad Crew made their debut in Extreme Championship Wrestling, defeating The Flamingo Kid and Georgie Love in Reading, Pennsylvania on November 3, 1995. Defeating George Love and Ranger Seven on November 17, the Bad Crew would feud with The Dudley Brothers in late 1995, losing to Dudley Dudley and Dances with Dudley at the supercard December to Dismember on December 4 as well as matches to Dances with Dudley and Buh Buh Ray Dudley later that month.
Feuding with The Headhunters during early 1996, the Bad Crew fought to a no-contest against J.T. Smith and Tony Stetson at House Party on January 5. On February 2, teaming with Mr. Hughes in a six-man tag team match, they also defeated Axl Rotten, Hack Meyers and El Puerto Ricano after Hughes pinned El Puerto Ricano in Reading, Pennsylvania and, the following month, the two would team with Judge Dredd in a six-man tag team match defeating Dino Sendoff, Don E. Allen and the Dirt Bike Kid at CyberSlam 1996 on February 17. They would also face JT Smith in several tag team matches with Joel Hartgood and El Puerto Ricano, including a bout at Just Another Night, before wrestling El Puerto Ricano and Damien Stone to a no-contest at Big Ass Extreme Bash on March 9, 1996.
Continuing to feud with El Puerto Ricano and the Dudley family, the Bad Crew would defeat El Puerto Ricano and Chubby Dudley on March 15 although they would lose to Buh Buh Ray Dudley and Big Dick Dudley in Glenolden, Pennsylvania the following night.
Returning to Reading, the Bad Crew defeating J.T. Smith and Chad Austin on March 29 and, while defeating The Gangstas by countout, they would lose several matches to The Pitbulls and Axl Rotten and Hack Meyers during the next few weeks. After participating in a 15-man battle royal in Plymouth Meeting, Pennsylvania on May 31, Bad Crew #1 and Bad Crew #2 faced each other in an impromptu match with Bad Crew #1 defeating Bad Crew #2.
Reuniting the following month, the Bad Crew fought to a no-contest against their former manager Damien Kane and Devon Storm in Reading, Pennsylvania on June 8 and defeated The Dudley Brothers by disqualification in Jim Thorpe, Pennsylvania on June 14 before losing to Devon Storm and Damien Kane in a rematch on June 21, 1996. The Bad Crew would lose to Ron and Don Harris on August 2, Buh Buh Ray Dudley and Hack Meyers at the supercard Unlucky Lottery on September 13, 1996 and the following night lost to The Sandman in a handicap match with Devon Storm at the ECW Arena in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.
In early 1997, the Bad Crew would lose to Stevie Richards and The Blue Meanie, The Gangstas, The Eliminators, and later lost a handicap match to Pitbull #2 in Scranton, Pennsylvania on April 4, 1997. They would make their last appearance in the promotion losing to Axl Rotten and Balls Mahoney in Downingtown, Pennsylvania on August 22, 1997.