Rosemary made her unannounced WWE debut on the August 27, 2024 episode of NXT, where she was chosen by Wendy Choo to be a surprise opponent for NXT Women's North American Champion Kelani Jordan. Rosemary would go on to lose the match to Jordan. On September 3, Rosemary would be defeated by Tatum Paxley and proceed to attack Paxley after the match alongside Wendy Choo, however both women would be thwarted by Lyra Valkyria, who came to Paxley's aid.