On January 5, 2017, Andrews was announced as part of the WWE United Kingdom Championship Tournament. Andrews defeated Dan Moloney in the first round, advancing to the quarter finals. On the second night of the tournament, Andrews defeated Joseph Conners, advancing to the semi-finals where he was defeated by Pete Dunne. On the February 22 episode of NXT, Andrews lost his NXT debut to Dunne. On November 7, Andrews teamed with Cedric Alexander, defeating Joseph Conners and James Drake on 205 Live. On the February 6, 2018 edition of 205 Live, Andrews announced his participation in the WWE Cruiserweight Championship Tournament, where he defeated Akira Tozawa in the first round, but lost to Drew Gulak in the second round on March 6, which eliminated him from the WWE Cruiserweight Championship Tournament.
On the March 27 edition of 205 Live, Andrews defeated Tony Nese, confirming his rematch against Gulak for the 205 Live episode after WrestleMania weekend. Andrews would lose the rematch and was attacked after the match by Gulak until Tony Nese made the save. On the November 7 episode of 205 Live, Andrews was defeated by the Cruiserweight Champion Buddy Murphy. On October 17, on the first episode of NXT UK, Andrews was defeated by Joe Coffey and was attacked after the match by both Joe and Mark Coffey until Flash Morgan Webster made the save. On October 29, Andrews defeated Wolfgang; after the match Andrews was again attacked by the Coffey Brothers with Webster making the save, however Wolfgang turn on them and joined the Coffeys in the attack.
In a triple threat tag team match at NXT UK TakeOver: Cardiff, Andrews along with Flash Morgan Webster captured the NXT UK Tag Team Championship after defeating James Drake and Zack Gibson to win the titles. After successfully defending the titles against Drake and Gibson, they lost the titles against Gallus (Mark Coffey and Wolfgang) on the October 17 episode of NXT UK.
In June 2021, vignettes started appearing on NXT UK programming featuring Andrews, Webster, and Dani Luna. In the following weeks, the group would be given a new entrance and theme music and start working together under the name Subculture.
Andrews was released from his WWE contract on August 18, 2022.