On January 27, 2024, Grace was a surprise entrant in the women's Royal Rumble match at Royal Rumble event, where she squared off with Naomi before ultimately being eliminated by Bianca Belair.
Grace then made a surprise appearance on the May 28 episode of WWE NXT, being revealed as the challenger for Roxanne Perez’s NXT Women's Championship at NXT Battleground. At the event, Grace failed to win the title.