On April 3, 2013, it was reported that Torito has signed with WWE. He made his debut on the September 30 episode of Raw, as the mascot of Los Matadores.
On January 26, 2014, El Torito participated in his first Royal Rumble match entering at number 20; eliminating Fandango before being eliminated by Roman Reigns. He scored his first victory in a ten-man tag match on the February 24 episode of Main Event, after pinning Heath Slater. He started his first rivalry, with Hornswoggle, of Heath Slater's 3MB. They fought at Extreme Rules, where El Torito defeated Hornswoggle in a WeeLC match. They had a rematch on the Payback pre-show in a Mask versus Hair match, in which Torito won again and proceeded to shave Hornswoggle bald post-match.
On March 29, 2015, a fatal four-way for the WWE Tag Team Championship took place on the WrestleMania 31 pre-show, with Los Matadores included, but they failed to win the titles.
On the September 7 episode of Raw, El Torito set up a distraction to Los Matadores during a tag team match against The Dudley Boyz, costing them the victory. Post-match, he was assaulted by Diego, but was saved by The Dudley Boyz who performed an aided superbomb through a table on him, ending his association with Los Matadores. Following the end of the stable as a trio, El Torito mainly appeared in backstage comedy segments, before not appearing on television any longer.
On May 6, 2016, after not making any appearances on WWE television that year, El Torito was released from WWE along with several other wrestlers.